Starboard Group Lenders
Testimonials
"
“Beth was professional, hard working, kind, and
understanding of a tough family situation involving 4
siblings. We did not make it too easy for her, but she
was everything we could ask for in a realtor. Highly
recommend.” - slatdog
"
- slatdog
"
“Our house had 3 full price offers within 7 days of listing with Beth Peyer! There was open communication and quick
response with emails, phone calls and texts.
Beth also helped us buy our dream home. We are truly happy and she was wonderful to work with!” - B. Johan
"
- B. Johan
"
“Beth listed our rental property and we received an
accepted oer in six days. She was very patient and
stopped by our home often, as we don’t have email or cell
phones, to get papers signed and to keep us updated.
She always had a smile on her face. We will be using her
to buy/sell our home in the future.” - Mary
"
- Mary
"
“Beth, and her calm, reassuring demeanor, got me
through what could have been a very stressful milestone:
preparing and selling my home. The property had an
accepted oer in 2 days. The “legwork” and paperwork
were completed thoroughly, without causing me worry. I
had enough worries as I prepared my new home!“ - Ina C.
"
- Ina C.
"
Beth, every time I see your photo I genuinely smile and remember what a kind and wonderful leader you were to the parents and children at Saint Ben’s when you were directing the catechism program. You were such a joy to be with- everyone looked forward to seeing you! You greeted, listened and helped and shared with all of us. We were so lucky to have you in that role! Absolutely unforgettable! As you in know, I’m still in the same home so I haven’t been lucky enough to work with you as a realtor, but I know from the years of positive experiences with you that your clients are in the very best of hands. After 30 plus years in ICU nursing there are times I entertain making a career change like starting up a fun business or even following in your footsteps to learn something new. You would be a great mentor so if I ever get brave enough to make a big change I’m calling you! One way or the other I’ll need you! Thanks for all your inspiring posts on Facebook! Amy Ahrens
"
- Amy Ahrens
"
“Best wisconsin agent. We met Beth over a year ago
to show us homes in the Country Club Estates area.
Throughout the entire buying process she was always
available with her expertise and knowledge of the market.
We were relocating as out of state buyers and she was
able to assist us in overcoming any issues that can occur
during the buying process. We would highly recommend
Beth Peyer as your real estate agent.” - Annette & Jerry J.
"
- Annette & Jerry J.
"
“My husband and I bought our 1st house this past April.
Having Beth as our realtor made the stressful and
unnerving house buying process worth it! Beth was
absolutely amazing! Her knowledge of the process and
the housing market was so great, especially for 1st time
home buyers like us, because we asked a lot of questions!
Buying a house has probably been the most stressful
thing I've experienced. With all the ups and downs in the
process, Beth was ecient and eective at problem
solving and negotiating. She was quick to respond,
organized, and motivated. My husband and I really felt
that she wanted our family to have the perfect home as
much as we did. Beth made us feel like we were her #1
priority.” - Roy & Megan Z.
"
- Roy & Megan Z.
"
“We highly recommend Beth as a realtor. We can’t say
enough about her thorough work on our behalf. She was
always available, responsive, organized and ecient. She
represented us and our interests during all steps of the
buying process, while patiently and diligently helping us
find the perfect home.” - Brian & Molly S.
"
- Brian & Molly S.
About Beth Peyer
Beth Peyer provides buyers and sellers in Lake Geneva and Southeast Wisconsin with steady, relationship-focused guidance rooted in years of teaching and community service. Her professional background includes leadership roles in education and faith-based organizations, where she developed a reputation for mentorship, communication, and helping others navigate important milestones. She brings that same commitment and clarity to every real estate transaction.
Licensed in Wisconsin since 2017, Beth serves as a REALTOR® with the Starboard Group at Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Starck Real Estate. Over the course of her real estate career, she has completed 32 transactions totaling more than $12.6 million in sales volume. She represents buyers and sellers across a variety of residential property types, working with first-time buyers, growing families, and clients relocating within or to Southeast Wisconsin.
Beth’s approach emphasizes trust, education, and clear communication at every stage of the process. Her ability to build meaningful relationships while providing informed, professional guidance makes her a valued resource for clients seeking both expertise and personal support in the Lake Geneva real estate market.
Metro MLS - Milwaukee Data provided by Metro MLS. All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers personal, non-commercial use and that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of the Multiple Listing Service. Information is supplied by seller and other third parties and has not been verified. Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Starboard Group may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. Copyright ©2026 - Multiple Listing Service, Inc. - All rights reserved.
Last Updated: September 21, 2026 4:17 PM UTC
